Based in Toronto and New York City

, Nancy Matsumoto is a writer and editor who covers sustainable agriculture, food, sake, arts and culture.

Sleepless at Citarella

Writer-director Nora Ephron loves food so much she puts her favorite shops in her hit movies

            When Nora Ephron’s screenwriter parents picked up and moved the family from New York to Beverly Hills, Ephron immediately knew they had made a horrible mistake. Never mind that she was only four-and-a-half.

            Then, as now, 50 years later, Ephron was someone who knew her own mind. “It’s one of my earliest clear memories,” she says. “I looked around in the beautiful golden sunshine of Southern California at all the happy, laughing children, and said to myself, “What am I doing here?”

            Ephron fled east as soon as she could, graduating from Wellesley and then immediately striking out for New York. Her first apartment was on Sullivan Street, near Little Italy. “I moved in the week of the Festival of Saint Anthony,” Ephron recalls. “I thought, ‘Oh my God! This is some sort of miracle that I’m living on a street where there are cannoli 24 hours a day!’”

            Ephron felt that she was home at last, and proceeded to prove to everyone else what she already knew: This town belonged to her. She leapfrogged from writing for the New York Post to crafting humor columns for Esquire and essays for New York magazine. Then, in the ’70s, while she was raising a family, she began writing screenplays.

            When her second marriage, to Washington Post star reporter Carl Bernstein, blew up, she turned heartbreak into venomous, hilarious payback in the form of a roman à clef, and then a movie, Heartburn. Her screenplays for Silkwood, When Harry Met Sally and Sleepless in Seattle (which she also directed) were nominated for Oscars.

            Her next film, You Have Mail, a remake of the 1939 Ernst Lubitsch comedy The Shop Around the Corner, will be set in her longtime neighborhood, the Upper West Side.

            An accomplished cook, Ephron belongs to that passionate breed of New Yorker that takes its food seriously. Herewith, in no particular order, is her top 10 list of food-related places that no one should come to New York without seeing. (Four of them will even appear in You Have Mail.) “If they were in Paris,” she says, “you would make a pilgrimage to them, you would change subways four times to get to them.”

            Zabar’s: “It embodies the quintessential New York emotion, which is unrequited love,” says Ephron. “All of Zabar’s customers love Zabar’s more than Zabar’s loves them. Every time you think you’ve got the place nailed down, they move the bread department somewhere else.”

            The Sullivan Street Bakery: “It seems as if a 6-foot-long pizza comes out of the oven every six minutes, and is sliced up and taken away on the spot. Truly one of the great eating experiences in New York.”

            Barney Greengrass: “The greatest delicatessen, bar none, and not cheap, either. Everything they make is the best there is. You can practically serve the borscht for dessert—it’s so delicious.”

            The Vinegar Factory: “New York’s version of Fauchon, only better. You’d be crazy not to buy your steaks here, because they sell the T-bone that is identical to the one served at Peter Luger’s.”

            Krispy Kreme Donuts: “Of course, the only donut to have is the original glazed, although the jelly donut is good, too.”

            Soup Kitchen International: “Which I’m proud to say we put into Sleepless in Seattle long before Jerry Seinfeld ever mentioned it.”

            Citarella’s fish decoration window displays: “In which they do things like the Stars and Stripes in squid and shrimp.”

            Dean & DeLuca: “Where my favorite thing is the ginger cookie made with cayenne pepper.”

            Custard Beach: (on East 8th Street): “The only place in New York that I know of that makes old-fashioned frozen custard.”

            Gray’s Papaya: Ephron says her neighborhood branch of this citywide hot dog stand “has arguably the most hilariously untouched décor—stacks of papaya boxes on top of one another. Of any place in New York, in its own way, I think it’s one of the most romantic restaurants in the city.”


P.S. So much has changed in the New York City culinary landscape since I wrote this, although many of the places she mentions are still around, and Nora Ephron is still working food into her movies as much as possible. She took command of the story as I imagine she does the movies she directs, micro-managing it with bossy confidence.

P.P.S. Ephron passed away in June 2012.

Glad Rags

The Starvation Club